Feedback to GM post: Guild Ranking changes

instead of gold it could be a special buff for Guild Member. (if member leave guild, he loose the buff)
1st = Drop / Gold / XP
2nd = Gold / XP
3rd = XP

OR
could also be:
1st = Drop / Gold / HPMP
2nd = Drop / DMG
3rd = EleDMG

the Drop / Gold / XP are fine
but the dmg and hp/mp buffs would be busted
having a strong permanent buff for a few select people only doesn't sound very balanced for the rest of the server
I'm gonna pass on that

[D0gm4]

instead of gold it could be a special buff for Guild Member. (if member leave guild, he loose the buff)
1st = Drop / Gold / XP
2nd = Gold / XP
3rd = XP

OR
could also be:
1st = Drop / Gold / HPMP
2nd = Drop / DMG
3rd = EleDMG

the Drop / Gold / XP are fine
but the dmg and hp/mp buffs would be busted
having a strong permanent buff for a few select people only doesn't sound very balanced for the rest of the server
I'm gonna pass on that

might be. just thought to give 2 others aditional dmg could compensate the HP/MP from 1st place.
in the end, its just a suggestion.

[shado]

1. they should disappear on the last day of the month, at the last minute

2. In my opinion, the prize should be really nice. Maybe an item that gives something to one player, then the players would be motivated to fight for it and the guild would have to fight for every player to receive it
e.g. pet lvl 10 or an item that draws you a different yellow in a given item or adds it if possible or other item something new one

3. No, only bosses should drop guild trophies.
do Kaligo normally 24/7
The teslon should also drop too 1 like every boss
and bosses in BS should also drop 1 guild trophy
but they shouldn't give exp
will bring more fight ther too on low lvls like CF

All rewards that give additional DMG are unfortunately excluded. They will clash with the BestDMG event, where the chances of getting all bonuses should be equal.

[Aook]

All rewards that give additional DMG are unfortunately excluded. They will clash with the BestDMG event, where the chances of getting all bonuses should be equal.

For that area you could block such buffs, and make it that only the class buffs works

A gold reward that can be easily split between guild members is still the best fair solution. Buff rewards can affect character balance and occasional events, so the only solution would be gold/drop buffs. Item rewards, on the other hand, have often caused disagreements within guilds/unions in the past, and we've often heard about that in Helpdesk reports.

As places to get the Trophy, these will most likely be:
Kaligo - for weaker players (with the planned change to party buffs in Chaotic Frontier)
Tesseris/Tesslon - for guilds and stronger players
Lydia - challenge level allows both weaker and stronger players to get it

If they were to be introduced in the drop of regular monsters (Infernum, Shinewood), the chance of obtaining them would be much lower. We will leave this for discussion. We may change the rules every month or so to test different solutions.

how u say kaligo is for weaker people when chn is there 24/7 full buff camping on entrance ?

[Nymeria]

Kaligo - for weaker players (with the planned change to party buffs in Chaotic Frontier)

They will finaly get rid of the party buffs in CF, so yeah, weaker players should in theory be able to participate.
Reality might be another, as most of end game players have full "cf" gear (low lvl uniqs 6/6, low weapons 8/8 etc). Still a HUUUUUUUGE W after almost 2 years of asking for the party buffs to be removed.

they heard players with delay is

how about reducing trophies from tesslon? its the only boss dropping so much. should be 1 as all others.

is the only ` Guild  Boss ` go fight for it !

[shado]

weak players have no chance to get kaligo there, removing pt buffs would give them some chance, like in BS

[Amoswar]

+1 to keep Kaligo 24h.
Will still be hard to get the boss, but at least it wont be 100% the person who has party buff who will have it.

Good